Showing posts sorted by relevance for query indiana toll road. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query indiana toll road. Sort by date Show all posts

Friday, August 22, 2014

Back home again in Indiana

And it seems that we can see...

That we were right all along (though under another blogging guise), and Max Sawicky, pgl and the gang at the Angry Bear were hilariously, stupefyingly amateurishly wrong about the lease of the Indiana Toll Road under Governor Mitch Daniels. Lowlights from back in 2006 being (via pgl);
... maybe the other 10 bidders refused to pay enough to the Governor under the table as he was so happy to claim $3.8 billion was better than his reservation price - a reservation price concocted by citing a really sloppy analysis.
And,

So the Governor – aided by what appears to be a faulty Crowe Chisek analysis are selling assets that may be worth $5 billion to private investors for only $3.8 billion. ...one might wonder of the Governor asked them to lowball the reservation price. In other words, is this some form of financial fraud imposed upon the taxpayers? Why would any responsible Governor be engaged in this kind of behavior? Oh but – we are talking about George W. Bush’s first OMB director.
As we pointed out at the time, the state of Indiana actually got about $8.2 billion from the 'winning' bidders, because in addition to the $3.8 billion check they cashed in 2006, the investors also committed themselves to $4.4 billion in upgrades and maintenance/repairs to the ITR. A toll road still owned by the state--they merely leased its operation to Cintra-Macquarie.

We also predicted (8 years ago!) that: In other words Macquarie-Cintra overpaid by about one billion dollars.

So, how's the deal looking for the Spanish-Australian consortium today?
The Indiana Toll Road Oversight Board has asked the Spanish-Australian investor group Cintra-Macquarie about the status of the payment it owes this month after state officials made similar inquiries after news reports that it was struggling last year to make an interest payment, board Director James McGoff told The Times of Munster.

"The answer is the same, they are trying to negotiate more favorable terms with their lenders," McGoff said.

.... Paula Chirhart, a senior vice president for Macquarie Group Limited, declined comment on the consortium's current financial situation.
Under the terms of the contract, if C-M defaults, then the toll road reverts to control by the state. Which gets to keep the $3.8 billion they've already received--and used to build new roads in Indiana--and they then would have the option of running the toll road for themselves, or...re-leasing it to some other investors for yet another one-time payment for its net present value.

All thanks to Indiana's then governor and, we are talking about George W. Bush’s first OMB director.

Tuesday, September 15, 2015

Got a bridge in Missouri I'd like to lease ya

Several of them in fact, since MDOT can't keep them in serviceable condition;
Hundreds of bridges across Missouri need repairs or replacing but the state agency that oversees bridges doesn’t have the money for the work, according to transportation officials.
The Missouri Department of Transportation says it’s still paying off debt it assumed for bridge work a few years ago and new funding sources are needed to make the necessary repairs and replacements. Meanwhile, some bridges around Missouri have to be closed rather than risk carrying traffic, The St. Louis Post-Dispatch reported.
Calling Mitch Daniels!
In much of the world, but only recently in the United States, private capital has begun to play a role, most often in partnerships with public authorities. ....

If it were merely a matter of getting hands on money today that would otherwise come in over the years, such partnerships would make little sense. The goal for states is to capture far more value than an asset would be worth if it remained in public hands. That goal is often not difficult to achieve.
That's from a 2006 NY Times Op-ed by the then Governor of Indiana explaining the very elementary economic reasons why he'd leased--for 75 years--the Indiana Toll Road to a profit seeking entity for a $3.85 million dollar up front payment. Which billions Indiana then used to not only build more roads within the state, but establish a maintenance and repair fund for its existing infrastructure.

And, btw, the 'winning' bidder, Spanish-Australian consortium Cintra MacQuarie also agreed to spend another $400 million on improvements and maintenance of the asset it had leased. Which is rather a better deal for the motorists of Indiana than what Missourians are being shown, is their future;
One bridge in need of work is the Highway H bridge, which carries about 1,800 vehicles per day over the Cuivre River a few miles northwest of Troy. MoDOT snow removal trucks, as well as other heavy vehicles can no longer safely cross the bridge and have to make a 31-mile, one-way detour, said Steve Miller, chairman of the Missouri Highways and Transportation Commission, which governs MoDOT.
Show me the money state?

Friday, March 28, 2014

Why don't you go with that, Mr. Obama

Billions and billions of dollars in trade between Windsor, Ontario and Detroit, Michigan, and the Obama Administration has a very good idea;
In a potential blow to a project that would speed traffic over one of the world's busiest trade routes, the Obama administration is holding back financial support for a customs plaza that is key to the future of a proposed international bridge linking Detroit and Windsor, Ontario.
Canada has already pledged to provide or guarantee private funding for most of the project's expected $3.65 billion cost, including $550 million for a connection between the bridge and U.S. Interstate 75. The Obama administration approved construction of the bridge last April, and Ottawa expected Washington to contribute $250 million to build the plaza, without which the bridge wouldn't be viable.
The bridge has support of Michigan's Republican governor and its two Democratic senators, among others in the state's congressional delegation. But U.S. officials say that there are limited infrastructure dollars and competing projects and that private money can step in on this bridge.
Maybe a phone call to ex-Governor Mitch Daniels might shed a little light on how to proceed. After all, the Canadian social security system currently owns the rights to the revenues from the Indiana Toll Road, for which the state of Indiana was paid almost $4 billion in 2006.

Contrary to the wailing and gnashing of teeth from the usual left-wingers at the time, it's worked out pretty well for Indiana, as they took the upfront payment and improved other roads and highways in the state. That led Honda to build a new auto plant in the state.

Tuesday, April 21, 2015

Die Wunder Bahnen

The richest country in Europe discovers that you can indeed, run out of other people's money. Even for traditionally public goods, so think outside the autobahn;
Germany's roads and highways are crumbling, its waterways and locks falling into disrepair. Much of this country's infrastructure has its structural heyday behind it, yet more patches is not what this leaky pipe needs.
Much will have to be replaced completely.
And financed. So, why not use professionals;
"The liquid bond markets are all but dried up, not least because of the bond purchases of the European Central Bank," said Gerd Weidenfeld, head of corporate finance at Gothaer. "They just don't offer any significant yields anymore."
With that in mind, the folks at Gothaer are increasingly investing their clients' money in infrastructure projects, which according to Weidenfeld offer a long and predictable lifespan and stable cash flow.
And the public gets new stuff to use, and drive on. As even French Communists realized some time ago;


Not to mention the Governor of Indiana, who explained the economics back in 2006 thus;
Without knowing what level of interest to expect, we offered to lease our toll road long-term to any interested operator willing to pay for the privilege. Independent estimates of the road’s net present value in state hands ranged from $1.1 billion to $1.6 billion, the latter figure aggressively presuming that all future politicians, unlike all their predecessors, would raise tolls at least in line with inflation. I had resolved that only a bid far in excess of that range would be worth advocating to my fellow citizens.
In the event, we received a best bid of $3.8 billion.
Which Indiana gleefully accepted, and used the money to build more highways. Clever, these Hoosiers.

Saturday, September 13, 2014

Maxspeak of the devil!

Last we saw of Max Sawicky he was hi-tailin' it away from his belief that Governor Mitch Daniels had given the people of Indiana a raw deal by leasing their toll road out from under them, on his way to a position giving his sage advice to Barack Obama. We're happy to see he's been let out on parole...

[Update: Max speaks;  I have never worked for the Obama Administration, or any administration.]


...and is at the movies;
Proof I’m getting old — I watched a Turner Classic Movie, and it was great: Murder, My Sweet, from the Raymond Chandler novel Farewell, My Lovely. (Not to be confused with the 1975 remake starring Robert Mitchum.) This one stars Dick Powell and people I’d never heard of, with the exception of Mike Mazurki. It came out in 1944.
Well, we always liked this one too, but Max passes over too quickly, its history;
The director was Edward Dmytryk. He had done some anti-fascist movies in the Forties. He later ran afoul of the red scare, did time, got blacklisted, eventually appeared before HUAC, and named names. He got back to working in the U.S. afterwards; the most memorable later effort was The Caine Mutiny.
I could detect no political memes in this film. [our bold]
That's because Dmytryk was a professional who went to great trouble to scrub the propaganda  his Communist friends put into the movie scripts he had to shoot. Such as what John Wexley produced for 1945's Cornered starring Dick Powell;
At every turn he inserted long speeches loaded with Communist propaganda thinly disguised as antifascist rhetoric--manifestoes by the dozen, but little real drama. Major surgery was in ordered. Wexley was allowed to finish the script, politely thanked, and dismissed.
And that dismissal of a Communist writer, for incompetence, landed Dmytryk in a whole heap of trouble with the man he refers to (with some accuracy) as the Gauleiter of Hollywood Communists, John Howard Lawson. He tells the story of his brief Communist fling--he joined the Party because it looked to be a wise career move in the Forties. I.e., Communists had real power in Hollywood back then, they could blacklist you from working!--in two books. It's a Hell of a Life But Not a Bad Living (1978) and Odd Man Out: A Memoir of the Hollywood Ten (1996).

Dmytryk was himself dismissed, from the CP, for failing to submit to Party discipline, by Lawson. But that wasn't the end of his troubles with the CPUSA. We'll get to that shortly.